Participants in the social media discussion deemed the rulings of the UN International Court regarding the Karabakh conflict ineffective.

Three years after the UN International Court's ruling on Armenia's lawsuit regarding refugees from Karabakh, the situation has not changed; such rulings do not lead to real actions, noted participants in the social media discussion. The UN International Court, like the UN itself, lacks mechanisms to enforce its decisions, and Azerbaijan reported to the court in a closed document about the measures taken, emphasized a Baku analyst.

As reported by "Caucasian Knot", leaders of three political parties from Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh submitted a statement to the UN calling for the enforcement of the ruling made three years ago by the International Court in The Hague regarding the return of the Armenian population to the region. At that time, the UN International Court in The Hague obliged Azerbaijan to ensure unhindered and safe entry or exit for people who left Nagorno-Karabakh as a result of events that occurred after September 19, 2023. The court also obliged Azerbaijan to preserve and not destroy documents confirming the property rights of residents of Nagorno-Karabakh.

On September 19-20, 2023, Azerbaijan conducted large-scale military operations and took control of the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, after which a mass exodus of the Armenian population began. Following the mass departure of residents of Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia, government officials were dismissed; however, the top leaders of the unrecognized Nagorno-Karabakh Republic continued to work in Yerevan. On January 1, 2024, the NKR ceased to exist according to the decree of its last president Samvel Shahramanyan. "Caucasian Knot" has prepared a report "The Beginning and End of the Unrecognized Republic of Artsakh" (Artsakh is the Armenian name for Nagorno-Karabakh).

On the "Caucasian Knot" Facebook page, the discussion of the appeal by Armenian public activists to the UN regarding the possibility of returning the Armenian population to Karabakh garnered 559 comments by 14:00 Moscow time. The discussion focused on the enforcement of international decisions, the circumstances of residents' departure in 2023, and mutual claims related to the history of the conflict. A significant portion of the discussion participants contrasts the current demands on Azerbaijan with previously unfulfilled UN Security Council resolutions, as well as raising questions about the return of Azerbaijani refugees, citizenship, security, and the preservation of cultural heritage.

Discussion participants reminded of the UN Security Council resolutions on Karabakh

One of the central themes of the discussion is reminders of the four UN Security Council resolutions from 1993 concerning the withdrawal of forces from occupied Azerbaijani territories and the return of displaced persons. Participants believe that the current appeal to international institutions should be considered in light of how similar decisions were previously implemented.

"Why were the four UN Security Council resolutions on the liberation of Karabakh lands from Armenian occupation and the return of Azerbaijani refugees not implemented?" asks Dilara Kuliyeva.

"In the end, Azerbaijan solved its problems by its own strength. So if you want to return to Karabakh, our fighters are eagerly waiting for you," wrote Vüqar Səmədov.

Commentators point out that the international organization, in their opinion, has failed to ensure the enforcement of its own decisions for a long time. Some participants doubt that the current appeals can change the situation.

The UN lost its authority when Armenia did not implement its four resolutions

"We also wrote to the UN for 30 years. For 30 years we waited for you to implement the document on the withdrawal of the Armenian army from Karabakh. In the end, we took up arms and liberated our lands," stated Nadir İsmayilov.

"The UN lost its authority when Armenia did not implement its four resolutions," believes Adil Baxshaliev.

"The UN doesn't care about this letter. Such issues are resolved only by force, not by empty actions," writes Tigran Nikoghosyan.

"Not everything is eternal, and not everything is bought and sold. There are still honest people and justice in the world. Soon everything will fall into place," expressed confidence Edik Mezik Keyan.

The voluntary departure of residents from Karabakh became a subject of discussion

Azerbaijani participants in the discussion insist that the residents of Karabakh left the region voluntarily. As an argument, they refer to video recordings of the departure and statements made by people while passing through the Lachin corridor.

"In 2023, when Armenians, taking their belongings, moved from Karabakh to Armenia, passing through the checkpoint, were interviewed by journalists, they all unanimously stated that they voluntarily refused to remain on the territory of Azerbaijan," wrote Ziya Guliyev.

This was a voluntary exodus, albeit conditioned by justified fears of future repression

"Armenians refused to live in Karabakh under the Azerbaijani flag and voluntarily left Azerbaijan," expressed the opinion of Ilgar Kuliyev.

"But this was a voluntary exodus, albeit conditioned by justified fears of future repression," noted Alessandro Ruotsi.

"I did not see that they wanted to return. They got into their cars and left, that's all. There are photos and videos," wrote Elnur Aliyev.

Some participants allow for the return of Armenian residents but link it to obtaining Azerbaijani citizenship.

"Let's say Azerbaijan allowed you to return. Permission is granted to those who lived in Karabakh before 1991 and who were born in Karabakh before 2023, who accept the citizenship of the Republic of Azerbaijan, who did not participate in battles against the Republic of Azerbaijan, who did not engage in separatism," suggested Oktay Mamedov.

"Citizens of Azerbaijan of Armenian nationality have the right to come and live in Karabakh after obtaining citizenship and taking an oath of allegiance to the Constitution of the Republic of Azerbaijan," wrote Azər Əhmədov.

In response to demands for the return of the Armenian population, many commentators raise the issue of Azerbaijanis who left the territory of Armenia in the late 1980s. Discussion participants believe that this problem should also be a subject of international attention.

"First, let 300,000 Azerbaijanis, who were forcibly expelled, return to Armenia," wrote Sam Senior.

A separate line of discussion is related to the number of Armenians who lived in Karabakh before the events of 2023. Some commentators dispute the figure of 150,000 people, pointing to discrepancies between the data provided in public statements.

"Now it's 150,000. Amazing, thought Ostap... The chairs are scattering like cockroaches," quoted "The Twelve Chairs" Samir Rajabov.

"There were never 150,000 Armenians living in Karabakh. At the best times for Armenians, there were about 120,000 citizens, of whom more than 40,000 were Azerbaijanis and representatives of other peoples," claims Tofiq Abdullayev.

"Mass expulsions and deportations of Azerbaijanis from the territory of modern Armenia in the 20th century occurred in several stages and began during the collapse of the Russian Empire and the creation of independent republics in 1918-1920," wrote Ruslan Afqanlı.

"Where did hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis, who lived for centuries on the territory of present-day Armenia, disappear? They all have documents confirming their identities, places of birth, and residence," stated Elman Zulfugar.

The return of the Armenian population to Karabakh sparked a discussion

Many discussion participants believe that the issue of returning residents should be considered within the framework of recognized state borders. Comments emphasize that Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan, and territorial disputes should not serve as a basis for revising sovereignty.

"Interstate borders are not a matter of emotions, but a matter of international law. For almost 30 years, about 20% of Azerbaijan's territories were under occupation, hundreds of thousands of our fellow citizens lived as refugees, and cities and villages remained in ruins. Azerbaijan returned its legitimate lands and restored territorial integrity," wrote Ruslan Ahadov.

"There is Karabakh, and it is an integral part of Azerbaijan," noted Orkhan Kh-ov.

In the comments, there are suggestions to consider the return of Armenians to Karabakh in conjunction with the return of Azerbaijanis to Yerevan and other settlements in modern Armenia. Thus, participants expand the discussion beyond the immediate Karabakh issue.

"Residents of the Yerevan Khanate also want to return to their homeland," wrote Fuad Gumbatov.

"First, let Armenia itself implement the four UN Security Council resolutions. Return all Azerbaijani refugees to their historical homeland in Yerevan, Goychamakhala, and Zangezur," stated Vagif Iskandarov.

Despite the predominance of mutual accusations and categorical statements, there are comments in the discussion about the need for peaceful coexistence. Some participants suggest separating the issue of political disagreements from everyday relations between neighboring peoples.

"Meanwhile, without this blind nationalism, our region could have long been a prosperous and peaceful home for all. Now miatsum is dead forever. And instead of living with phantom pains and dreaming of revenge, it is time to finally accept this reality and build peace based on respect for borders," believes Ruslan Ahadov.

"Neighbors need to live peacefully," wrote Afa Agaev.

The analyst called the acceptance of Azerbaijani citizenship a condition for the return of Armenians to Karabakh

According to Baku analyst Toghrul Juvarly, a member of the Azerbaijani National Public Committee for Eurointegration, Azerbaijan sent a report on the measures taken to The Hague back in January 2024. However, such documents are confidential, and their content is not published, he told a correspondent of "Caucasian Knot".

At the same time, he noted that the public position of official Baku regarding the UN Security Council decision of November 17, 2023, was expressed late in the evening of the same day in a statement by the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry.

The statement from the Foreign Ministry stated that Azerbaijan took note of the UN International Court's decision in the case of "Armenia vs. Azerbaijan" regarding temporary measures in connection with the application of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD) dated November 17, 2023. "We welcome the court's decision, which once again confirms Azerbaijan's territorial integrity and its sovereignty over Karabakh," the press release states.

Baku, Juvarly continued, guaranteed Karabakh Armenians all rights, security, property protection, and return to the region on the condition of accepting Azerbaijani citizenship and reintegration into the life of the country.

Juvarly reminded that the Azerbaijani authorities then created a special portal where Karabakh Armenians could apply for Azerbaijani citizenship.

At the same time, the analyst continued, Baku put forward a reciprocal demand for the mirror right of return for Azerbaijanis expelled from Armenia in the late 1980s.

The expert emphasized that against the backdrop of the Karabakh conflict, about 200,000 Azerbaijanis were forcibly displaced from Armenia, who lived compactly in a number of districts, and in the Vardenis and Krasnoselsky districts constituted an absolute majority.

Moreover, according to Juvarly, back in January 2023, Azerbaijan filed a lawsuit memorandum against Armenia in the International Court of the UN in The Hague under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination.

In this document, Azerbaijan accused Yerevan of conducting ethnic cleansing, destroying 95% of civil infrastructure and cultural heritage in the Karabakh region, as well as massive landmining, which resulted in hundreds of casualties after the 2020 war, based on evidence collected in the territories returned under Baku's control in 2020.

Baku, the analyst noted, demanded that the court recognize Armenia's responsibility for human rights violations, incitement of hatred, and obstruction of the return of hundreds of thousands of forcibly displaced persons. In addition, the Azerbaijani side insists on disclosing information about the missing persons, restitution of property, and holding those responsible accountable under international law.

The withdrawal of lawsuits would be the optimal solution for concluding peace

Juvarly emphasized that over the past five years, Azerbaijan and Armenia have filed a number of lawsuits against each other, and no substantive decisions have been made on any of them. He explained the lack of decisions by the lengthy procedural process, the right of the parties to objections, which also require investigations.

At the same time, as Juvarly emphasized, during the negotiation process to achieve a peace treaty, the parties reached an agreement on the mutual withdrawal of all interstate lawsuits from international courts. This is reflected in the text of the "Agreement on Establishing Peace and Interstate Relations between the Republic of Armenia and the Republic of Azerbaijan," initialed in August 2025 in Washington.

Juvarly believes that the mutual withdrawal of lawsuits is the most optimal solution on the path to achieving lasting peace. According to him, Azerbaijan will not agree to the demands for a "collective return" of Karabakh Armenians to the region and granting them some status that undermines the sovereignty of the country.

"If Armenia officially raises this issue, then Azerbaijan will reciprocally raise the issue of recognizing a similar right of return for Azerbaijanis expelled from Armenia. Terminating litigation is even more beneficial for Armenia, as during the years of occupation, it caused material damage to Azerbaijan amounting to tens of billions of dollars," said Juvarly.

The UN International Court lacks mechanisms to enforce its decisions, it does not have its own police to enforce orders

He also pointed out that the UN International Court does not have mechanisms to enforce its decisions.

"The UN International Court lacks mechanisms to enforce its decisions, it does not have its own police to enforce orders," said Juvarly.

In general, the UN itself lacks mechanisms to achieve the enforcement of its decisions.

"Even UN Security Council resolutions are very rarely implemented. On the other hand, in the UN Security Council, the decisive word lies with the five permanent members, among whom there are deep contradictions, and any of them can veto decisions," noted Juvarly.

At the same time, he pointed out that the international community has accepted the post-conflict realities in the South Caucasus, and now the signing and ratification of a peace treaty remains to finalize the end of the conflict.

The addressees of the appeal did not respond to it

On the website of the UN International Court, as well as on the pages in the social network X, there is no reaction from the addressees of the appeal from Armenian parties - UN Secretary-General António Guterres, President of the UN International Court Yuji Iwasawa regarding the appeal of leaders of three parties from Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh in connection with the three-year anniversary of the UN International Court's temporary measures adopted at Armenia's request.

Source: https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/428500