The lawsuit from the resident of Sochi threatens the property of 17 gardeners.
A resident of Sochi, Galina Mizareva, is demanding through the court to correct the boundaries of the plots of 17 neighbors in the gardening community to gain access to her home. The defendants in the lawsuit fear losing part of their land and housing.
On November 19, 17 owners of plots in the housing gardening community "Avangard" in the Sochi microdistrict Plastunka received copies of the lawsuit from their neighbor Galina Mizareva. She has approached the Central District Court of Sochi with a demand to remove obstacles to the use of her plot and residential house: Mizareva is demanding to organize a passage and access to her house by changing the boundaries of neighboring plots.
The defendants told “Kavkazsky Uzel” that they disagree with the demands and intend to defend their property in court. They insist that they own the plots legally, have ownership documents, and do not prevent their neighbor from using existing access roads. According to Mizareva, they have not seized common land.
In her lawsuit, Mizareva states that her plot occupies 537 square meters, on which there is a residential house with an area of 62 square meters. She obtained ownership rights in 2021. According to her, the previously existing passage and access were blocked after the surveying of neighboring plots more than 15 years ago, and the current boundaries deprived her of the opportunity to access her territory.
The gardeners dispute this version. According to them, all plots and the system of common access roads were formed in the early 1990s, and the owners have been using this infrastructure for decades. Mizareva's family, they say, also regularly comes to the house and uses the common road.
The defendants believe that the plaintiff is seeking a separate access from the main road, which bypasses the territory of the community with more than a hundred plots. They suggest that this may be related to a desire to increase the attractiveness of the property for sale.
The lawsuit affects 12 plots
Mizareva is asking the court to oblige the 17 owners to correct registry errors in the location of the boundaries and bring them in line with the project of organization and development of the community and ownership documents. 12 plots are named in the lawsuit.
The plaintiff refers to the conclusion of a cadastral engineer from the company “Regional Cadastral Center” dated June 17, 2026. According to her, the conclusion states that several neighboring plots were surveyed in such a way that the passage provided for in the project was blocked.
She also refers to a judicial land management examination by the company “Cadastr-Expert” in civil case No. 2-818/2023. According to Mizareva, during the surveying of the Rastegaeva plot, about 130 square meters of common land were added to its area. The defendants disagree with this interpretation: they claim that cadastral discrepancies were resolved in court more than 15 years ago.
To the lawsuit, Mizareva attached a copy of the decree of the head of the Central District Administration of Sochi dated October 1, 1993, No. 684/4 “On the re-registration of rights to land for 123 plots with an area of 6.56 hectares of the housing gardening community ‘Avangard’”, a list of community members, and the project of its organization and development.
These documents allow for a comparison of the original layout with the current cadastral boundaries, the defendants believe. They hope that “the court will sort it out” when they present the original master plan of the community.
The community has existed for 35 years
The community was officially formed in 1991, said Alexandra Rastegaeva – one of the defendants who grew up in this area.
“All members of the gardening community had gardening books, as was required at that time. The plots were distributed, their boundaries and access were determined with the participation of community members and relevant authorities,” she said.
According to Rastegaeva, the plot that Mizareva acquired in 2021 previously belonged to other owners. During all the time of their ownership, there were no claims regarding the lack of access or passage to it.
In 2009, when registering plots under the new land legislation, problems arose with cadastral numbers and overlapping boundaries, said Nina Dubovaya – another defendant who has lived here since the community was formed.
“There was an overlap of 20 land plots with a total area of 14,508 square meters. The problem was resolved in court, which took the community members two years. We went to court from 2009 to 2010 to eliminate all discrepancies, understanding that none of the gardeners were to blame for the mistakes made during the cadastral accounting,” Dubovaya explained.
The gardeners did not seize common land, said defendant Tikhon Rastegaev. After the court proceedings in 2010, his family received a new cadastral number for their plot.
“The plaintiff writes in the lawsuit as if our family and other members of the gardening community added land to themselves through self-seizure, and because of this, she cannot access her plot. This is not true. All boundary issues were considered in court more than 15 years ago. We did not seize anything,” Rastegaev emphasized.
According to him, since acquiring the plot in 2021, Mizareva has not made any claims to the owners that someone blocked the road or common access.
The defendants fear for their homes
The defendants are particularly concerned about the possible change in the boundaries of the plots on which residential houses stand. The plaintiff's demands affect part of Nina Dubovaya's plot, where her house is located, she claims.
Mizareva's family threatens to demolish the house, Dubovaya claims. “I tried to talk to Mizareva out of court, but instead of a conversation, her son-in-law began to threaten me with the demolition of my house. He told me directly: ‘I will make sure your house is demolished’,” she said.
Access can be organized from the side of the ravine, where, according to Dubovaya, there is free common land, but this will require costs for soil stabilization. “I personally built a retaining wall on my plot. The land in Sochi is complicated, creeping. But taking away someone else's labor and property is, at the very least, unfair,” the gardener believes.
Viktor Mishchenko, whom Mizareva links in the lawsuit to the blocking of access, calls her claims unfounded. “I have been using my plot since the very beginning of the community's existence. The plaintiff acquired the land in 2021, and now she is making demands on several owners, although we all use the common access roads and passages that have existed since the community was formed,” Mishchenko said.
Other defendants, including Olga Zavadovskaya, Tatyana Turchenko, Tamara Matveeva, Svetlana Kurushina, Evgeny Kozlov, and Alexander Amelin, also disagree with their neighbor's demands. In their opinion, before changing the boundaries of existing land holdings, it is necessary to establish whether the plaintiff really has no access to the common road and whether there are other access options.
Legal assessment
In her lawsuit, Mizareva refers to Articles 11.9 and 60 of the Land Code of Russia, Articles 274 and 304 of the Civil Code of Russia, as well as Article 61 of Law No. 218-FZ “On State Registration of Real Estate”. Article 11.9 prohibits the formation of plots if it deprives access to common land. Article 61 defines the procedure for correcting errors in the information of the Unified State Register of Real Estate.
The court will have to determine whether there are indeed cadastral errors, when they arose, and how much the changes will affect the rights of the owners, believes lawyer Sergey Kabanov, who is not involved in this dispute.
“When correcting a registry error affecting the rights of owners, it is necessary to establish the specific circumstances of its occurrence and the legal grounds for changing cadastral information. An additional question is the possibility of establishing a servitude. According to Article 274 of the Civil Code of Russia, the owner of real estate has the right to demand limited use of someone else's land plot to ensure passage or access if their needs cannot be met in another way. However, a servitude does not mean the expropriation of land from ownership: the owner retains the right to the plot, but its use is limited by the established encumbrance. The conditions of such use and possible payment are determined by the agreement of the parties or the court. Mizareva does not directly request the establishment of a servitude in the petition part of the lawsuit – she asks to correct registry errors and change the boundaries of neighboring plots to ensure passage and access to common land. Therefore, the court will have to establish whether there are indeed cadastral errors, when and under what circumstances they arose, as well as how much the proposed changes will affect the rights of current owners. An important circumstance will also be the availability of alternative access to the plaintiff's plot. In judicial practice, when considering claims for the establishment of a servitude, the possibility of ensuring passage or access in another way and the degree of burden on neighboring owners are taken into account,” Kabanov explained.
The gardeners believe that it is necessary to find out why the existing access order, which other owners use, cannot be applied to the plaintiff's plot. In their opinion, actual use of the road does not in itself replace the establishment of its legal status, and this issue may become the subject of judicial investigation.
The Central District Court of Sochi confirmed receipt of Mizareva's lawsuit against the owners of the community plots. “An open court session is scheduled for November 24,” a court employee told a correspondent of "Kavkazsky Uzel".
It was not possible to obtain a comment from Galina Mizareva for “Kavkazsky Uzel”; no response was received from the phone numbers of her representatives indicated in the lawsuit.