The court in Baku rejected additional investigation in the case of Mamedli and Abdullayev.
The Baku Appeal Court refused to satisfy the defense's motions for a re-examination of evidence and questioning of witnesses in the case of the imprisoned head of the Election Monitoring and Democracy Training Center Anar Mamedli and freelance journalist Anar Abdullayev.
As reported by "Caucasian Knot", on September 22, 2025, at a court session in Baku, the head of the Election Monitoring and Democracy Training Center Anar Mamedli compared his case to the practices of Soviet repressions. On July 24, the prosecution requested 14 years of imprisonment for Anar Mamedli and 13 years for Anar Abdullayev. On September 7, the court sentenced Anar Mamedli to 13 years in prison and activist Anar Abdullayev to 12 years. Their lawyers claimed political motivation for the prosecution and the lack of credible evidence of guilt.
Anar Mamedli was detained in Baku on April 29, 2024, and arrested on charges of smuggling in connection with the case of employees of the Abzas Media publication. Later, his case was separated into a separate proceeding. In May 2025, new charges were brought against Mamedli: illegal entrepreneurship, legalization of illegally obtained property, tax evasion as part of an organized group, and forgery of documents. The case has been sent to court, and the defense insists on Mamedli's innocence. Freelance journalist Anar Abdullayev (Abdullayev) is also accused in Mamedli's case.
A preliminary hearing in the case of the head of the Election Monitoring and Democracy Training Center (EMDTC) Anar Mamedli and activist and freelance journalist Anar Abdullayev took place at the Baku Appeal Court on November 17, chaired by Judge Mehriban Garayeva.
According to a human rights defender observing the process, the defendants and their lawyers petitioned for the consideration of complaints with a partial re-examination of the court proceedings and additional investigation of several circumstances of the case.
According to the source, Anar Abdullayev's lawyer Gunay Ismayilova stated that there is no evidence of her client's guilt in the case. She pointed out that none of the witnesses questioned in the first instance court testified against her client. "There is no evidence of a specific fact of smuggling — that Anar Abdullayev traveled anywhere and brought something. It is unclear on what basis this person was sentenced to 12 years in prison," the observing human rights defender quoted the lawyer's words.
"The defenders of both defendants stated the need for additional study of several circumstances of the case, emphasizing that without this, the appellate instance cannot make a reasoned decision," the interlocutor continued.
In particular, according to him, the lawyers demanded clarification on whether receiving grants that have not undergone state registration constitutes a criminal offense. In this regard, they petitioned to send a request to the Constitutional Court, referring to the decision of the Plenary Session of the Supreme Court that acquitted human rights defender Rasul Jafarov in compliance with the verdict of the European Court of Human Rights.
In 2019, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe called on the Azerbaijani authorities to lift the convictions of eight activists known collectively as the "Ilgar Mamedov group," whose rights violations were recognized by the Strasbourg court. Among these activists are Ilgar Mamedov, Rasul Jafarov, Zaur Gurbanly, Anar Mamedli, Intigam Aliyev, Uzeir Mamedli, Rashadat Akhundov, and Rashad Gasanov. In January, the leader of the "Republican Alternative" party Ilgar Mamedov appealed to the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe, urging them to suspend Azerbaijan's powers in this structure due to the authorities' failure to comply with the European Court's decision. In March, the Council of Europe again called on Azerbaijan to lift the convictions of the activists. On April 23, the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan reviewed the cases of Mamedov and Jafarov and acquitted them.
Additionally, the defense demanded to send requests to international organizations mentioned in the criminal case. "Anar Mamedli stated that he collaborated with various organizations based on service contracts, under which election monitoring, human rights activities, and other projects were carried out. According to him, all activities were conducted in accordance with the law, and taxes were paid from the received funds," the source noted.
According to him, the defenders also stated that the originals of many documents in the case are missing, and the materials presented to the witnesses were also not originals. According to the lawyers, the signatures on the existing documents are forged, and the handwriting does not belong to Anar Mamedli.
"However, the judicial panel rejected all defense motions. According to the court's decision, the appellate complaints will be considered without questioning witnesses and examining additional evidence, that is, without additional judicial investigation," the source said.
Mamedli's lawyer Elchin Sadigov confirmed in a conversation with a correspondent of the "Caucasian Knot" that the defense's motions were not satisfied by the court. In his opinion, without questioning witnesses, additional investigation of all circumstances of the case, and an objective attitude towards the defense's arguments, the consideration of the appeal will turn into a mere formality.
At the same time, he particularly emphasized that the mere use of grants, even if they were not registered, cannot be considered a criminal act, since, according to Azerbaijani legislation, this is classified only as an administrative offense. Moreover, grant funds cannot be considered "smuggling," as they were provided by well-known international organizations, the lawyer added.
According to him, the date of the next court session has not yet been set.
A BAS employee informed the correspondent of the "Caucasian Knot" that the parties will be notified in advance about the time of the next session.
As reported by the "Caucasian Knot," PACE rapporteur on political prisoners Azad Rojan and the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights Michael O'Flaherty pointed out the political motivation behind Anar Mamedli's sentence. They called on the Azerbaijani authorities to immediately release the human rights defender and review the sentence imposed on him.
The European Parliament also called on the Azerbaijani authorities to release Ali Kerimli, Anar Mamedli, and other political prisoners, while the European Union considered the possibility of targeted sanctions due to human rights violations.