The mother of the girl beaten by her stepmother from Chechnya spoke about her condition 12 years later.

THIS MATERIAL (INFORMATION) WAS PRODUCED AND DISTRIBUTED BY A FOREIGN AGENT LLC "MEMO", OR RELATES TO THE ACTIVITIES OF A FOREIGN AGENT LLC "MEMO".

The girl beaten by her stepmother in 2014 was left disabled; she requires regular rehabilitation procedures, but there is no money for treatment. Her mother, Madina Visitaeva, appealed to the head of Chechnya for help with housing. A blind young man gives her massages; communicating with him provides her with additional psychological support.

As reported by "Caucasian Knot", on July 19, 2014, a four-year-old girl with multiple injuries was brought to the hospital in Grozny. The investigation established that the child was tortured by her stepmother before hospitalization. The child was in a coma for two weeks and then underwent long-term treatment in clinics in Moscow. She underwent surgeries at the Leonid Roshal Center for Pediatrics and Emergency Children's Surgery and at the ENT department of the Moscow Regional Research Clinical Institute. The authorities of Chechnya took on the costs of the child's rehabilitation. In 2019, doctors examined the girl and concluded that she could successfully undergo rehabilitation in Grozny. At the same time, the Ministry of Health of Chechnya placed the responsibility for the delay in her treatment on the girl's mother.

According to the girl's mother, her daughter had her last surgery in 2016 in Moscow, and the doctor asked her to come back in 2-3 months for preventive treatment. However, the woman said she could not go to Moscow due to financial problems, and the deputy minister of health, who was always dealing with the hospitalization issues ... (of the girl) in Moscow, did not answer calls. There was also no response regarding the payment for treatment from the Akhmat Kadyrov Foundation, the child's mother stated. In turn, the head of the department for motherhood and childhood, Elita Satarova, promised the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot" to consider the issue of the girl's treatment in Moscow soon.

Madina Visitaeva had already appealed to the Akhmat Kadyrov Foundation seven years ago for another quota for rehabilitation treatment for her disabled daughter. "I specifically addressed this request to the president of the Foundation, Aymani Kadyrova. I sent a letter by mail," she told the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot" on November 17.

However, according to her, the letter either did not reach its destination or there was some other reason, but she did not receive a response to her request. Now her family faces another problem, which she dared to address directly to Kadyrov. "I decided not to send the letter by mail but to come to Grozny on Kishiyev Avenue and hand it to those who will pass it on, if not to the head, then at least to those who can help me," Madina said.

Her 19-year-old son, Khamzat, who has suffered from a serious chronic illness since early childhood, signed a contract and has been participating in military actions in Ukraine for almost a year. "Every month we receive 30,000 from him to pay for the apartment we rent in Urus-Martan. Khamzat signed the contract for this, for his younger sister, so she could continue her treatment and studies in the school program," Madina admitted.

I am raising three children alone; my ex-husband has not participated in raising the children and does not help.

According to her, living in a dilapidated grandmother's house in Tangi-Chu, where three other families also reside, her daughter is deprived of this. "I have no housing. I am raising three children alone; my ex-husband has not participated in raising the children and does not help. We have nowhere to live and no one to ask for help," reads the letter to the head of the Chechen Republic, a copy of which is available to "Caucasian Knot".

"Dear Ramzan Akhmatovich, you help many disabled people and those in need; please help my family find a roof over our heads," Madina appealed to the head of the republic.

Relatives shared details of events from 12 years ago

Madina Visitaeva is the mother of the girl who was so brutally beaten by her stepmother in July 2014. Fatima, Marha's sister, was eight years old at the time. "It was in the evening; Marina, that was the stepmother's name, was bathing [the sister]. She wanted to take a cup to pour water on herself but slipped and accidentally hit the stepmother in the face with the cup. The stepmother got angry and started beating her. First with the cup, then with a brush. I don't remember what else she beat her with, but she beat her for a long time, until blood came. [The sister] was screaming and wouldn't calm down. Then Marina grabbed her by the hand and started banging her against the wall with all her might. After several such blows, [the sister] fell silent, her eyes closed, blood on her face. Marina got scared, threw her on the floor, and for some reason grabbed Khamzat, started shaking him and shouting: "Massargha a ishtta ala! Ditta t1era ohhayshna iza!" (Tell everyone she fell from a tree! Tell everyone!) She pulled out her phone and started calling for an ambulance. And to those who answered her, she also said that the child fell from a tree. And she ordered us girls to say that [the sister] didn't want to bathe, climbed a tree, fell from there, and got hurt," Madina recounted her daughter's story.

She beat us all, pulled our hair hard, but [the sister] got it the most.

"The ambulance arrived quickly; the doctor asked us how it happened. Only Khamzat said what Marina told him to say, while we, three girls, remained silent. Although we were also afraid of the stepmother. She beat us all, pulled our hair hard, but [the sister] got it the most," Fatima told the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot".

It is quite possible that the public would not have learned about this incident if Zalina Lokaeva from television had not reported it in two lines on social media in the morning. Besides the "short info," Zalina knows nothing, and the management advised her to "remove this information from social media, saying that such cases with stepmothers are rare and should not be emphasized."

However, in conversations with doctors at the city children's clinical hospital No. 2, it turned out that such cases, where stepmothers beat and mistreat children born from the first wife, are not rare. "Some of these individuals are quite inventive in their attempts to get rid of children born from the first wife," a doctor told the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot" on the condition of anonymity.

The police arrived, and it turned out that the girl was regularly beaten by her stepmother.

According to him, he first learned about how stepmothers torture children during his first year as a surgeon. "It was about two years after the case with [Madina Visitaeva's daughter]; I was on duty at the hospital, and around midnight, a five-year-old girl was brought in by ambulance. Her body was covered in bruises, her head was broken, and the X-ray showed old fractures of the collarbone, forearm, and two ribs. 'How old was the child when all her bones were broken?' the nurse on duty with me gasped. The police arrived, and it turned out that the girl was regularly beaten by her stepmother. I later learned that a criminal case had been opened against the stepmother," he recounted.

A former law enforcement officer called the use of violence by stepmothers against children from the first marriage a problem.

A former law enforcement officer, who once provided many journalists with information for columns on judicial chronicles, told the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot" on the condition of anonymity that cases where stepmothers mistreat completely helpless children are much more numerous than those that have made it to the internet.

Experts believe that the actual number of conflicts and facts of harsh, and sometimes cruel treatment by stepmothers towards children in remarriages is higher, but cases rarely reach court.

"The main issue in Chechnya is the latent nature of the problem. Experts believe that the actual number of conflicts and facts of harsh, and sometimes cruel treatment by stepmothers towards children in remarriages is higher, but cases rarely reach court. Relatives try to 'not air dirty laundry' and resolve issues within the family or clan. Well, now against the backdrop of the SVO, this topic has completely faded, but it exists," the interlocutor is convinced.

In several cases, he helped ensure that criminal cases were opened against the subjects of the case. "Magomed's parents divorced, and his father remarried. The boy's biological mother lived on the neighboring street. And the little boy, missing his mom, would run to her. The stepmother was angry about this. For this, she regularly and cruelly beat the boy and eventually chained him to the heating radiator. The story became public in November 2014 thanks to the vigilance of neighbors and relatives on the mother's side. The guardianship authorities and police confirmed the fact of systematic torture during the inspection. The court officially ruled to take the boy from his father and transfer him to the custody of his biological mother. A criminal case was opened against the stepmother for the torture of a minor. This was the only court decision that returned the child to his mother," he provided as an example.

He also spoke about other cases. "A high-profile case in the village of Novye Atagi (2013-2014) was opened against a 22-year-old stepmother who abused her husband's two minor children. In August 2014, the court found her guilty not just of torture but of attempted murder (part 3 of article 30 - points 'a' and 'v' of part 2 of article 105 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation) and sentenced her to 10 years in prison. A case in the village of Bachi-Yurt (2017). A criminal case was opened against the stepmother and her husband, the biological father of the girls aged 10 and 11, under part 2 of article 117 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation for systematic beatings and abuse. The court imposed real prison sentences on both. A case in Grozny (2018) under part 2 of article 117 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation was opened against a 43-year-old resident of Grozny. The investigation established that the woman systematically beat her 10-year-old girl and 8-year-old boy (children from her husband's first marriage) with a stick while their father was not home. A case of violence against the stepson (2022-2023). In the Grozny district, a case was investigated against a 53-year-old woman who abused her minor children (3 and 4 years old) from her stepson, who lived in the same house. In addition to systematic beatings, the stepmother forced the toddlers to take life-threatening medications. In July 2022, the court found her guilty under part 2 of article 117 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation," the former police officer listed.

A human rights activist called for holding the fathers of children beaten by stepmothers accountable.

According to human rights activist Svetlana Anokhina, in such cases, the husbands of stepmothers should sit on trial alongside them.

"In the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, there is article 125 ('leaving in danger') and article 156 ('failure to fulfill duties for raising a minor'). A father, returning home after work or a long business trip, says he did not notice bruises or signs of beatings on the small child. The investigation proves that he knew about the abuse (he could not have missed the bruises, not noticed the exhaustion, or the marks on the hands from ropes), but did not take any action to protect the child, and for this reason, he should sit on trial alongside the stepmother as an accomplice," she stated to the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot".

According to Anokhina, she cannot name a single case where regional law enforcement agencies held fathers criminally responsible for the unlawful actions of their new wives against their children.

A man who brings a woman into his home who injures his children is not a protector but an accomplice to the crime.

The human rights activist noted that "from the perspective of Islam, a man bears personal and unavoidable responsibility before the Almighty for each member of his family." "The Prophet Muhammad said: 'Each of you is a shepherd, and each of you is responsible for his flock.' A man who brings a woman into his home who injures his children is not a protector but an accomplice to the crime," Anokhina believes.

In her firm conviction, the only way to stop these tragedies is to stop forcibly separating small children from their biological mothers during divorce. If the Caucasian society and courts unconditionally followed the norms of child protection (both in Russian law and in pure Sharia) and left small children with their mothers, cruel stepmothers would simply not have the physical opportunity to commit these crimes.

She also believes that the beginning of the SVO has pushed the problems of domestic violence and the rights of children far into the background for local authorities. And this gives free rein to domestic tyrants. In the closed nature of the region, controlling what happens behind closed doors with 'foreign' children from first marriages has become practically impossible.

The beaten girl was left disabled; she requires constant rehabilitation.

A neurologist, one of the leaders of the state budget institution "Republican Children's Rehabilitation Center," told the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot" on the condition of anonymity that the beaten girl "spends two weeks in this center three times a year." "Moreover, completely free of charge," she emphasized.

Many know what trials she has faced and pity her. This is also a kind of psychotherapy for the girl.

"Here [the girl] receives 10 sessions with a speech therapist and psychologist. In addition, every day the girl has therapeutic physical education, procedures in the physiotherapy department, and massages focusing on her right limbs. During her stay in the center, she actively communicates with those who work there. Here [the girl] is known, as she has been attending the rehabilitation center since she was four years old. Many know what trials she has faced and pity her. This is also a kind of psychotherapy for the girl," the interlocutor believes.

According to her, after each stage of the girl's stay in the center, doctors hold a council and give recommendations. The girl, who is now 16 years old, suffered a severe closed head injury at the age of 4. The psychologist confirmed the previous diagnosis: cognitive function impairment with uneven cognitive activity, reduced memory productivity, attention, speech, thinking, and slowed information processing. "According to his recommendations, [the girl] needs regular sessions with a psychologist aimed at maintaining and developing cognitive memory functions. It is also recommended to use tasks that are accessible in complexity, step-by-step instructions, material repetition, and additional time for completion. The speech therapist noted a systemic speech underdevelopment of moderate severity. She recommended conducting logomassage of the tongue muscles (the girl's mother was taught how to perform this procedure); the girl needs to regularly engage in articulatory gymnastics," the doctor reported.

She also noted that rehabilitation procedures need to continue. "Many well-known child psychologists and neurologists-rehabilitators believe that even 12 years after a severe injury, the brain's neuroplasticity allows compensating for many difficulties and significantly easing the teenager's life," the doctor is convinced.

According to Madina, these 13 days in the center are often filled to the brim for her daughter. "I see that she gets tired but does not whine; she does everything the doctors require of her. At the same time, for example, the psychologist recommends regular sessions. And this means that for each such session, payment is required, and transportation costs must be covered since [the daughter] is disabled. Her right leg hardly functions, and such expenses do not fit into our family budget. So these recommendations remain only on paper," she said.

Her right arm and leg hardly function.

"Her right arm and leg hardly function. It is very difficult for her to walk, and this greatly irritates her. Moreover, the rehabilitation center reassured us, saying that the leg can be treated, but regular massages are needed. But where can I get the money for this?" the woman sighs.

Earlier, a neurologist-rehabilitator from one of the Moscow rehabilitation centers, commenting on the girl's situation, told the correspondent of "Caucasian Knot" that she needs to "regularly undergo rehabilitation." "However, 2-3 courses a year for two weeks is only a supportive push, but for forming stable neural connections and strengthening the process of muscle memory, the brain and muscles need daily, measured support during breaks between hospitalizations," she added.

A blind young man agreed to give the injured girl massages.

The correspondent of "Caucasian Knot" recalled the story of a young resident of Grozny Madina Avlarigova, who, while pregnant, spent almost all of January 1995, during the storming of the city, sitting in a basement in the very center of the city. The stresses she experienced during the bombings did not pass without a trace - the boy was born blind. They endured hardships, sometimes blatant mockery when the boy grew up, and Madina began knocking on the doors of all ministries and departments in Chechnya to get a referral for study at the Kislovodsk College for Blind Children, where boys and girls were trained for professions. The correspondent contacted Avlarigova, who stated: "Of course, Bekhan will give her massages. Write down our address and let them take all the medical records. And if there are any, the X-rays too. And tell them - no money!"

Communicating with Bekhan is a significant psychological and rehabilitation resource for the girl in her condition.

According to Madina, her daughter immediately established such a warm and trusting contact with Bekhan, as if they had known each other for a long time. "Communicating with Bekhan is a significant psychological and rehabilitation resource for the girl in her condition," Madina Avlarigova believes.

"Bekhan loves and knows how to work with children. Very sick little children are brought to him. But I have never heard a child cry. He knows how to talk to them so quietly and calmly that the mothers who bring their children start to doze off," she laughs.

"My daughter watches the clock to see what time the massage is scheduled and starts nudging me in advance so we won't be late," Madina Visitaeva said.

She also mentioned that her daughter's stepmother has already been released from prison. "On the night of July 19, my girl was taken to the hospital by ambulance. Early in the morning, I was in Grozny; I did not leave the hospital yard for several days, waiting for my daughter to regain consciousness so I could see her in the ward. Then the doctor came out and told me to give him my phone number, that they would inform me when [my daughter] comes out of the coma. And he told me to go home. 'Rest, you need to gather strength; you will need it,' the doctor said to me. Since then, for 12 years, I have been constantly by [my daughter's] side. Always, every day," Visitaeva shared.

Visitaeva shared details of her acquaintance with her ex-husband.

According to her, she dreamed of entering a medical college after the ninth grade and then working as a nurse. "My grandmother had no legs, only two stumps above the knees. When her family was taken to Kazakhstan in exile, she got caught under the wheels of a wagon. My grandmother made her own shoes: she wrapped the stumps in rags and pulled galoshes over this construction. She often got sick, and she had to go to the FAP for injections, which was far away. I had to learn to give injections and then put in droppers at my grandmother's insistence. We lived very poorly; my parents had eight children, and there was also the family of my father's older brother. In a two-room house built before the deportation, more than 20 people lived. I dreamed of leaving to study at a medical college and then working in a hospital. I wasn't thinking about marriage at all; the main thing was to get into college," Madina recalls.

It was Magomed Yusupov. A week later, his aunt, who was a distant relative of ours and a relative of the Yusupovs from the other side, came to us. That's how I was married off.

But the second Chechen war began. Young men started to disappear, and Madina's classmate was killed. "We barely survived the winter; the war rolled back into the mountains, but it was still uneasy. We stopped being surprised by mass killings, robberies, and violence. According to her, almost everyone lived in semi-starvation, except for those families that managed to remain wealthy at all times. One of the representatives of this class noticed the pretty girl on the bus when Madina and her brother were going to Urus-Martan for medicine for their mother and grandmother. "It was Magomed Yusupov. A week later, his aunt, who was a distant relative of ours and a relative of the Yusupovs from the other side, came to us. That's how I was married off," the woman sighed.

In her soul, she was against this marriage, but her opinion did not interest anyone. "We were given a week to get to know each other. He came to Tangi-Chu twice. I would go out; we stood at the end of the street, while about a hundred meters away, my younger brother was loitering out of boredom. That's how it is. The groom told me something, and I nodded my head in agreement; after a while, my brother made all sorts of signs to me, meaning enough. At home, my sisters asked, 'So, how do you like him?' And I honestly replied, 'Not at all!'" Madina admits.

Then, having lived for some time in this family and giving birth to a daughter, Fatima, she developed a sense of gratitude, but not towards her husband, who by that time had brought a second wife into the house, but towards Zina, her mother-in-law, who treated her, the first daughter-in-law, very kindly.

The family of Magomed Yusupov grew; Madina had a son, then a second daughter, while the second wife had two girls. "We got along with the second wife; we did all the household chores together. The children also had no conflicts. This was until Marina Baisultanova appeared in the house. Everything and everyone irritated her, especially the children. I began to notice that if she encountered any of the girls on the way, she would grab them by the hair and push them aside, as if joking, but painfully. Khamzat got it the least, but the girls did not get off lightly: she hit them for every little offense," Madina recalls.

Scandals began in the house, which were always provoked by Marina.

She remembers that once she saw Marina hitting the younger girl of the second wife. She shouted at her, threatened to tell her husband. "In short, scandals began in the house, which were always provoked by Marina. She managed to get him to send us home with the second wife, while the children were to stay with him," Madina continues.

"I was not against leaving, but only with the children. He started shouting that this would never happen, got angry, began to beat me and push me out the gate. 'I will still take the children, you will see!' - this was the last thing I managed to say. According to her, her husband hit her hard on the head, and she fell," she continued.

We updated the applications on Android and IOS! We would appreciate criticism and ideas for development both in Google Play/App Store and on the pages of the Caucasian Knot in social networks. Without installing a VPN, you can read us on Telegram (in Dagestan, Chechnya, and Ingushetia - with VPN). Through VPN, you can continue to read "Caucasian Knot" on the website as usual and on social networks Facebook*, Instagram*, "VKontakte", "Odnoklassniki" and X. You can watch videos from "Caucasian Knot" on YouTube.

* the activities of the company Meta (which owns Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp) are prohibited in Russia.

Source: https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/428430