The ECHR recognized the preventive detentions of activists in Baku as illegal.

The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg ordered the authorities of Azerbaijan to pay compensation for the short-term detentions of politician Tofiq Yagublu, as well as activists Idris Amir Aslan and Aziz Mamiyev.

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) announced today its decision on the complaints of Azerbaijani activists Idris Amir Aslan and Aziz Mamiyev, as well as politician Tofiq Yagublu. The opposition members filed complaints regarding their detentions during protests in Baku in 2021 and 2022.

As noted in the ECHR decision, Amir Aslan and Mamiyev were detained by police on December 15, 2021, during a protest on Fountain Square in downtown Baku. Politician Yagublu was detained on November 11, 2022, in front of the city administration building during a protest against amendments to the law "On Political Parties."

Security forces in Baku disrupted a protest on December 15, 2021, demanding the release of activist Saleh Rustamov, who had been on hunger strike for 40 days that day. More than 20 participants of the protest were detained. During the protest of the Azerbaijan Popular Front Party on November 11, 2022, in Baku, at least 150 people were detained, and about 50 others were detained before the protest began. According to human rights defenders, excessive force was used during the detentions.

In both cases, the police dispersed the protesters a few minutes after the events began, although the applicants had notified the authorities in advance about the protests, as noted in the ruling on the ECHR website.

All three opposition members were taken to police stations after their detention, where they were held for about two hours without the possibility of leaving freely. No detention protocols were drawn up, and the reasons for the restrictions were not explained to them. In the case of Amir Aslan and Mamiyev, the fact of their presence in the station was recorded in the logbook, but no such entry was made regarding Yagublu.

The Azerbaijani government, in its objections to the ECHR, claimed that the police actions were aimed at preventing violations of public assembly rules, but the court found these arguments unconvincing.

In cases of preventive detention, authorities are required to justify a high risk of committing a specific offense, and the case materials indicate that the main goal of the security forces was to prevent peaceful assemblies, the court pointed out.

The ECHR ruled that the authorities of Azerbaijan violated the rights of all three opposition members to liberty and personal security (Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights) and to freedom of assembly and association (Article 11). According to the court's decision, Azerbaijan must pay each of the three applicants 3,000 euros as compensation for moral damage and an additional 500 euros to cover legal costs.

The ECHR's decision is precedent-setting for considering complaints about short-term detentions, noted a Baku lawyer who wished to remain unnamed.

“The Azerbaijani government often explains such detentions during protests by claiming they are necessary to prevent unlawful actions. However, the court in Strasbourg found these arguments unsubstantiated, stating that authorities must prove the existence of a high risk of a specific offense. Otherwise, detaining a person constitutes a violation of the freedom of assembly, even despite the unapproved nature of the protest,” the lawyer told a correspondent of the "Caucasian Knot."

The Azerbaijani representative at the ECHR, Chingiz Askerov, was unavailable for comment. Tofiq Yagublu is currently in custody on new criminal charges.

Source: https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/428421