The Chechen historian established little-known details of the deportation of Chechens and Ingush.
Historian Mairbek Vachagaev* is preparing to publish a new work dedicated to the Stalinist deportation of Chechens and Ingush. The archival documents found by the historian allowed for a detailed description of the conditions of transportation for the deported and their lives at the settlement site.
On February 23, 1944, the operation "Chechevitsa" began, during which nearly 500,000 Chechens and Ingush were forcibly evicted from the territory of the Chechen-Ingush ASSR to Kazakhstan and Central Asia. More details about these events and their consequences can be read in the reference material of the "Caucasian Knot" "Deportation of Chechens and Ingush".
Documents concerning the deportation of Chechens and Ingush, which had not been studied previously by researchers, were discovered by historian Mairbek Vachagaev* in regional archives of Kazakhstan. According to the historian, he has dedicated the last two to three years to actively working on the topic of the deportation of the Vainakh people.
“This topic is not new – today there are hundreds of works on this subject, touching on various aspects of this undoubtedly significant work. Scholars, publicists, and authors of fiction illuminate the deportation of peoples in the former USSR in different ways, but despite all this, there always remains something unsaid. That is, the topic requires constant work on numerous questions, and this pushes you to engage again and again with this terrible page in the fates of the peoples subjected to mass deportation. I am one of hundreds who pay attention to this topic abroad, in Russia, and today often in Kazakhstan. The topic is so vast that it is unlikely anyone will ever be able to cover it completely,” he told a correspondent of the “Caucasian Knot”.
In the last 30-40 years, researchers have provided numerous facts that allow classifying Stalin's deportations as a crime against humanity, he noted.
“Nevertheless, the new young generation does not perceive the events of the distant 1940s-1950s in the same way. They are no longer as interested; one could say they have grown tired of it against the backdrop of a rapidly developing world. But it is not enough to say that you are Chechen, Ingush, Balkar, Karachai, Crimean Tatar, Kalmyk, or Volga German by passport – it is necessary to be connected through the history of your people and your neighbors, viewing it not only through the prism of continuous victories but also through understanding the tragedy and everything that has happened to your people over the past centuries. Not to boast about history, but to accept it with dignity and respect for those who created it for millennia before you,” Vachagaev* stated.
In this context, the historian calls the topic of deportation “completely limitless”. “It encompasses both personal tragedies and the courage of those expelled from their lands. This includes the power apparatus in the form of the NKVD and NKGB, which tried to maintain total control over the deported; it is a state that failed to save them from incredible losses outside of war, and the attitude towards the deported from society, which was also varied and contradictory, depending on many factors; and personal relationships that have persisted decades later in the memory not of the deported themselves, but of their descendants,” Vachagaev* explained.
Thousands of documents discovered during his trips to Kazakhstan have lain in local archives for the last 70-80 years – at the district, regional, and republic levels. “These are the regional archives of Aktobe, Kostanay, Akmolinsk (Kokshetau), Kyzylorda, Turkestan (the archives are still stored in Shymkent), North Kazakhstan (Petropavlovsk), Pavlodar, Semey (Abay region), Ust-Kamenogorsk (East Kazakhstan), Zhambyl (Taraz), Taldykorgan (Taldykorgan), Almaty (the regional archive is located in the village of Almalabak), and Karaganda regions, as well as in the city archives of Kokshetau, Shymkent, Kyzylorda, Pavlodar, Ust-Kamenogorsk, Kostanay, and also at the district level, such as in the Shieli district of Kyzylorda region. And, of course, it is necessary to mention the archive of the President of Kazakhstan in Astana, where all documents related to the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Kazakhstan and the Almaty regional party committee are stored. Also in Almaty are stored documents of the Soviet government of Kazakhstan and others,” Vachagaev* listed.
On October 22, Mairbek Vachagaev* published a fundraising campaign on the GoFundMe platform for a final trip to Kazakhstan to study regional archives. “If there are no surprises, I will close all 14 regional archives,” he wrote. As of today, the fundraising is 94% complete: out of the target amount of 4,000 euros, 3,758 euros have been raised.
He noted that today one should not expect to find any revolutionary documents in the archives that could fundamentally change the existing understanding of the deportation of peoples. “These documents can help better understand what actually happened during the years of resettlement of the expelled peoples. It should be noted that during the post-Soviet period, many documents have been published not only in the form of collections but also in individual articles: most often, the author tries to contribute and introduce a new document into scientific circulation. Yes, during the Soviet era, they were all, without exception, closed to mass research, and only a few people were allowed to shed light on them – with the aim of proving the guilt of the expelled peoples and whitewashing the policy of the communist regime. With the collapse of the USSR in 1991, there was a tsunami of publications of documents on this topic, all of which are valuable to this day. Without them, you cannot write and work on this topic today. Even those who justified the regime in the 1980s began to speak of the criminality of the regime and the tragedy of the peoples after the collapse of the country,” Vachagaev* pointed out.
Mairbek Vachagaev* provided a facsimile of one of the many documents: it indicates that a year after the arrival of the special settlers in Kazakhstan, there was a failure to meet the plan in all aspects of their provision. Such letters and reports from below continued to be recorded in subsequent years.
The historian reproduced the conditions of transportation for the deported
Studying archival documents allowed the historian to establish specific parameters for the movement of the deported: up to 50 people per 17 meters in a carriage.
“I saw this carriage in Pavlodar, where an exhibition of World War II times is set up outdoors: there, among other things, stands this carriage – as evidence that in the region tens of thousands of special settlers were transported in carriages of this type, which were intended for transporting livestock. They were also used to transport horses to the front; by the way, only eight horses were allowed to be transported in the carriage, although for the sake of economy, they could be transported to the front line in greater numbers against instructions, but this was an exception rather than the rule. That is, four horses per half of the carriage, while the number of people transported was limited to 40. I was surprised by this carriage: if 40 people was the maximum, it was clear why Lavrentiy Beria decided to increase it to 44-45 people per carriage. But if with horses this is more or less understandable, then with people the size was slightly reduced due to the fact that three shelves for luggage were constructed on one side. From the very beginning, it was decided to abandon luggage carriages for each convoy – instead, the cargo hastily taken by people remained with them, which compacted them regarding the size of the carriage,” the expert explained his conclusions.
At the same time, the convoy lists compiled by the guard troops and submitted to the local NKVD after arrival at the destination most often contain different figures.
“Namely, 52-54 people per carriage based on the example of the convoys. For example, convoy No. 6, which arrived in Ust-Kamenogorsk: in the 12th carriage of the convoy there were 51 people, in the 10th carriage of the same convoy there were 54 people, and so on. And we are talking about a carriage whose size was slightly more than 17.5 square meters! Visually, try to imagine 54 people in a room of only 17 square meters,” he pointed out.
In addition to luggage shelves, there was a potbelly stove in the carriage: it was located in the center and was heated once a day during stops.
“One bucket of coal was allocated for each carriage. That is, the dimensions of the carriage were reduced due to the shelves and the potbelly stove; to relieve themselves, they most often tried to wait for a single stop per day at some section; such stops were intended to be two dozen from Grozny to the farthest point – Leninogorsk (now Ridder) in East Kazakhstan. That is, between what Beria intended and what actually happened, there is a significant difference – by ten people, which made the movement of the expelled practically an act of survival,” Vachagaev* stated.
According to these lists, we see comments from the guards: “body left at an unnamed stop”, “died on the way”, “remove from the carriage”, “child born”
A convoy with 65 carriages could not have the speed typical of those years, from 30 to 40 kilometers per hour – they moved at an average route speed of 150-250 km per day; about 6-10 kilometers per hour considering long stops. The entire journey, ranging from 2,500 to 3,500 kilometers (depending on the destination of the convoy), took from two to three weeks: although there is a recorded fact of the first convoy arriving in northern Kazakhstan already on the 12th day, but this was more of an exception than a rule.
“With such a load of people in the carriages, there was also no shortage of diseases: along the way, the authorities were forced to detach carriages and leave them in quarantine and then send the carriages to their destination. The figures are provided by Beria in his report on the completion of the special operation "Chechevitsa": it mentions 1,272 deceased people, and 56 children were born on the way. He received this figure from the report of the commander of the convoy troops of the NKVD, General Bochkova, dated March 21, 1944 , where he reported on the completion of the transfer of Chechens and Ingush to Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. If we take the average figures of the convoys that arrived in Ust-Kamenogorsk , then the mortality rate in these convoys exceeds the official data by two times regarding the arrival of all at the place of determination. One of the last recorded convoys arriving at the final station should be considered the one that arrived at the station Leninogorsk ,” Vachagaev* continued.
The mortality rates among the deported are understated in the authorities' reports
According to the convoy lists, which recorded all changes during the trains' journeys, it is evident that the mortality rate among the deported was several times higher than the figures indicated by the authorities.
“But for the final closure of this issue, access to all convoy lists is needed. They have been preserved and are available in Russian archives, but for some reason have not yet been provided to researchers for review. According to these lists, we see comments from the guards: “body left at an unnamed stop”, “died on the way”, “remove from the carriage”, “child born”, “removed from the carriage due to suspicion of typhus” and so on. That is, the material is very valuable and useful for study by researchers, and there is no reason today to consider it secret and hide it from public access,” Vachagaev* emphasized.
He added that similar work has already been done by German scholars. “They have practically restored all the convoy lists of Germans from the Volga in 1941. Poles and scholars from the Baltic states have also done a lot in this direction. Why is what is not secret for Germans from the Volga still secret regarding Chechens? There is no logic. I hope that the publication of a new wave of documents on this topic will lead to clarification of figures and understanding of new aspects of the special resettlement regime – as well as show how much of this was isolated cases or systemic violations of the rights of the deported by the authorities. I tend to believe that the authorities are responsible for the fact that the mortality rate among the deported exceeded the birth rate in the first five years, from 1944 to 1949,” Vachagaev* also stated.
The research work on the material is still ongoing. Upon its completion, Mairbek Vachagaev* plans to publish several books; the first volume will serve as a kind of reference book on deportation.
“Those who are familiar with what I am engaged in are certainly interested and waiting for the final material. The first volume – which will cover events before the eviction, the very fact of eviction, arrival, distribution, and survival in the first year in Kazakhstan – will be ready soon. I do not intend to present it as if it will contain something completely new: much has been done before me, but I saw my task as presenting and showing grassroots documents, depicting the picture through the eyes of local officials – whether they were NKVD officers, collective farm chairmen, or mine managers, showing attitudes towards the deported. That is, I want to personalize this history so that people see not just documents but also imagine how all this was perceived by those who lived in that difficult time,” Vachagaev reported.
He is confident that everyone interested in the topic of deportation will find many new and detailed facts in the work that will allow them to better understand what happened in 1944 to people deprived of their historical homeland due to unfounded accusations.
The documents allow us to see the picture that has formed around the special settlers: how the authorities at the grassroots level turned the population against those arriving from another region, how what was intended for the resettled was plundered, how children and the elderly starved and died en masse, how people were deprived of their rights, how their demands and needs were ignored – not for a good life, but solely for survival, how the expelled lived in hope of return.
“All the books that will be published on this topic will be accompanied by hundreds of new documents from the archives of Kazakhstan. Taking this opportunity, I want to thank all the Kazakhstani archivists who sincerely helped me for their participation in the search for documents,” Vachagaev* concluded.
Vachagaev's colleagues appreciated his approaches to research
Mairbek Vachagaev* is a recognized professional who has very good achievements in working with archival documents, reported Georgian historian, Professor Merab Chukhua to the “Caucasian Knot”.
“His material is always well-founded. Whether to engage in the history of deportation now is not even a question: if every 50 years at least in the 'Russian Empire' genocide against Chechens is committed – and this is precisely how the Council of Europe recognized the deportation of Chechens – then there is nothing to discuss,” he said.
According to the professor, today it is important for historians to learn the true motives behind the deportation of a number of peoples. “Evictions occurred at a time when Nazi Germany was close to defeat, and this still seems absurd. Why did Stalin take on this plan and cleanse the North Caucasus of its peoples? In 1944, the Soviet Union was already advancing and was at the door of Berlin. And because they felt the strength that the USSR had gained largely thanks to the support of allies. But the military aid directed against fascism was directed by the Soviet leadership against the peoples of the 'Russian Empire',” Chukhua believes.
He also noted Mairbek Vachagaev's* innovative approaches to studying the history of the Mountain Republic. “I know that he is working in this direction, and I have also had to touch on this topic. In general, this topic has not received extensive discussion for some unknown reason either in Russia or in the South Caucasus, although the Mountain Republic declared its creation here in Georgia, in Batumi – and it was the first state to proclaim independence in the Caucasus. The independence of the Mountain Republic predates even Georgian independence in terms of declaration. It issued its own currency and even received recognition from Germany and Turkey. It was a parallel process with what was happening in Georgia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan. Of course, in the political reality we have today, the Mountain Republic does not fit; and the very name 'Mountain' reflected the remnants of the Russian imperial approach, when all the peoples of the Caucasus were called 'mountaineers', which does not reflect reality – for example, Circassians lived on the plain and on the seashore. But this does not mean that we should abandon our history. The very fact that such a state existed is, of course, a huge achievement of the then leaders,” Chukhua summarized.
Any new source introduced into scientific circulation is significant, especially in the topic of Stalin's deportations, believes historian Patimat Takhnaeva. According to her, the historiography of the problem of the deportation of the Vainakh has gone through several fundamental stages, during which the methodology, degree of access to archives, and assessments of the event itself changed.
“Currently, there is a transition from simply accumulating facts and publishing documents to a deep analysis of historical memory, generational trauma, and narrative languages. After publication, let readers decide how Mairbek's work fits into trends,” Takhnaeva noted.
She noted that she is familiar with Vachagaev's* work on the history of the Mountain Republic and finds it convincing. This work, according to Takhnaeva, is mainly written based on sources from Russian archives, but when discussing the lack of political recognition of the Mountain Republic, the author also cites documents from French archives.
"Caucasian Knot" also reported that in 2015, Mairbek Vachagaev, who headed the French Association for Caucasian Studies, transferred 50,000 archival sheets on the history of the Caucasus to the Archive Administration of Chechnya. According to Vachagaev, he transferred archival documents to Chechnya for the "absolute majority of the population of the North Caucasus, who are interested in the history of their people." These previously unknown documents are of immense value, as they reveal details of events from 1917-1921 in the Caucasus, historians interviewed by the "Caucasian Knot" indicated.
We have updated the applications on Android and IOS! We would appreciate criticism, ideas for development both in Google Play/App Store and on the pages of the Caucasian Knot in social networks. Without installing a VPN, you can read us on Telegram (in Dagestan, Chechnya, and Ingushetia – with VPN). Through VPN, you can continue to read the "Caucasian Knot" on the website, as usual, and on social networks Facebook**, Instagram**, "VKontakte", "Odnoklassniki" and X. You can watch videos of the "Caucasian Knot" on YouTube. Send messages to WhatsApp** at +49 157 72317856, in Telegram – to the same number or write to @Caucasian_Knot.
* included in the Russian register of foreign agents.
** the activities of the Meta company (owns Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp) are banned in Russia.