The initiative of Dagestani villagers has sparked criticism towards officials.
The independent purchase and installation of a transformer by residents of one of the villages in the Tlyaratinsky district, who did not want to wait for repairs due to the threat of being left without electricity in winter, showed that officials have shifted the responsibility for infrastructure onto the villagers themselves, and now they can also attribute the results of the work done to their reports, residents of Dagestan stated on social media.
As reported by "Caucasian Knot", on November 14, it became known that residents of one of the villages in the Tlyaratinsky district of Dagestan independently acquired a new transformer and replaced the old equipment to avoid being left without electricity in winter. According to the villagers, the repair of the faulty transformer could take from six months to a year, so they decided to raise money and replace it themselves.
The initiative of the residents of the Tlyaratinsky district to replace the transformer sparked a discussion on social media about the authorities' responsibility for the state of infrastructure. Residents of Dagestan criticized the need to independently pay for the replacement of equipment in the comments to the post and expressed doubts about the integrity of accounting for such work.
Some commentators suggested that the equipment purchased by the residents might later be presented by officials in reports as installed at the expense of state funds. Such assessments are found in the comments to the post published on November 15 by the Instagram*-public makhachkala_.
As of 09:40 MSK on November 16, this post in the Instagram*-public makhachkala_, which has about 258 thousand followers, received 483 likes and 29 comments.
Residents of Dagestan discussing the villagers' initiative criticized the authorities for forcing people to solve the electricity supply problem on their own. They pointed out that providing settlements with necessary infrastructure should not be shifted onto the villagers themselves.
"Some might think this is very good, but in reality, it shows that people are so illiterate or that there is so little law in Dagestan that people have to buy a transformer themselves. In any other region of Russia, people would write to the appropriate authorities and they would have this transformer installed for free!" – believes marzhana0279.
"And the authorities only think about taxes," – noted tmfgg875.
"Shame on the authorities!" – exclaimed tlcdbg.
Other participants in the discussion pointed out that after the independent purchase of the transformer, the villagers continue to pay for electricity.
"On paper, they put in a new one, supposedly, but in reality, it's used. They report that they acquired a new transformer. There has been so much of this in the villages. A couple of months – and it burns out. So people are already taking it upon themselves and installing it. The same goes for motors for water supply in villages. They buy pipes at their own expense. And the management writes that they bought them. They write off the money. It's high time for people to raise these issues," – stated ir.bi.s.
"And they will come from the office, put it on the state's balance sheet. They will write off the money, supposedly that they installed it. They will become the owners," – suggested rashidm51.
"And then you will pay for everything by the meter to the last penny," – noted kazim0887.
As of 09:40 MSK on November 16, there are no comments regarding the independent purchase and installation of the transformer by residents of one of the Dagestani villages on the websites of the Tlyaratinsky district administration and the company "Rosseti North Caucasus".
"Caucasian Knot" also reported that residents of Dagestan periodically solve electricity supply problems independently. For example, in March 2025, residents of the village of Erpeli in the Buynaksky district replaced a transformer with raised funds, stating that appeals to officials and energy workers went unanswered. The independent replacement of equipment later turned into a legal problem related to its registration.
In December 2023, residents of the village of Tsumilyukh in the Tlyaratinsky district complained to the President of Russia about infrastructure problems, stating that they also had to purchase transformers, poles, and wires independently. In November 2020, residents of the Makhachkala settlement of Semender reported that they installed transformers and laid power lines to their homes at their own expense.